By the end of this lesson you can
- Qualify a load in one call
- Counter with a number and a reason
- Know when to walk away
Start here
The simple version
Think of it like this: Negotiating is like trading cards with a friend. You both want a fair deal. You say what you need and why, and you meet somewhere in the middle.
- Before you talk price, ask questions about the load.
- Let the broker say a number first if you can.
- Ask for more with a reason, like a long empty drive to get there.
- Never go below your walk-away rate. It's okay to say no.
Words to know
- Counter-offer
- Saying a different price than the one offered.
- Detention
- Extra pay when the truck waits too long to load or unload.
- Live unload
- The truck waits while the freight is taken off.
- Drop trailer
- The truck leaves the trailer and drives away without waiting.
Got the idea? The full lesson below goes step by step, with real examples, practice and checklists.
Qualify before you quote
A rate is only good if the load is what you think it is. Ask these before you give a number:
- Pickup and delivery addresses, dates and times. Appointment or first-come, first-served?
- Commodity, weight, pallet count, and whether it's floor-loaded or palletized.
- Equipment and any special requirements (temperature, tarps, straps, team, hazmat).
- Is it a live load / live unload or a drop trailer? Who unloads, and is there a lumper?
- Detention policy: free time and hourly rate. Layover and TONU terms.
- Payment terms and quick pay options.
- Any extra stops, and whether they are paid separately.
How to counter
Brokers make money on the difference between what the shipper pays and what the carrier gets, and they want to cover the load. You want the best rate the market will bear for this truck, today. The broker usually knows the shipper rate; you know the truck's costs and the reload picture. Use what you know.
- Let the broker give a number first when you can: "What's the best you've got on this one?"
- Counter with a specific number and a reason: deadhead, a weak destination market, a tight appointment, extra stops.
- Leave room to meet in the middle, but never below the carrier's walk-away rate.
- If you can't agree, give the broker your number and say you can do it if it's still open later. Many loads come back.
Call scripts
- Dispatcher
- Hi, this is [name], dispatching for [carrier], MC [number]. I'm calling on your [origin] to [destination] load for [date]. Is it still available?
- Broker
- Yes, it is.
- Dispatcher
- Great. I've got a [equipment] empty in [city] at [time]. Can you confirm weight, commodity and the pickup and delivery times?
- Broker
- ...
- Dispatcher
- Is it a live unload or drop? What's your detention policy? What are you paying on it?
- Broker
- I can do $1,900.
- Dispatcher
- I appreciate it. We're 80 miles deadhead to get there and [destination] is a slow market to reload out of. I'd need $2,250 to make it work.
- Broker
- I can't get to that. Best is $2,050.
- Dispatcher
- Meet me at $2,150 and I'll confirm with the driver now and send the setup packet in five minutes.
Example numbers only. Always get the carrier's approval before you confirm a load.
When to walk away
- The broker won't give the rate, the terms, or the delivery details in writing.
- The rate is far above market with pressure to commit now (a common fraud pattern, lesson 9).
- The rate is below the carrier's walk-away number.
- The pickup or delivery times can't be met legally on the driver's hours.
Practice scenario
The broker won't move
Example numbers. A broker offers $1,700 on a 650-mile load. Your truck is 70 miles out, the destination is a slow market, and the carrier's walk-away is $2.40 per true mile. The broker says $1,750 is the most they can do.
Your turn:
- What is the minimum you can accept?
- How do you respond?
- What do you do after the call?
Think it through, then show the model answer
- 720 true miles × $2.40 = $1,728. $1,750 clears it, but only just.
- Counter once with your reason (deadhead, slow destination). If they hold at $1,750, it meets the minimum: ask the carrier whether they want it, and if yes, confirm detention terms and ask for the rate con.
- Review the rate con line by line, get the carrier's approval, send the setup packet if needed, and log the broker and rate in your broker list.
Common mistakes
- Quoting before you know the weight, times and unload type.
- Countering without a reason.
- Agreeing terms on the phone that never make it onto the rate con.
- Confirming a load before the carrier approves it.
Load qualification checklist (for the call)
Keep it open while you call a broker.
Load # ___ Broker ___ MC ___ (checked ✓) Pickup: address ___ date/time ___ appt / FCFS Delivery: address ___ date/time ___ appt / FCFS Commodity ___ weight ___ pallets ___ floor/palletized Equipment/requirements ___ (temp / tarps / straps) Live or drop? Unload by ___ Lumper? ___ who pays ___ Detention: free time ___ rate $___/hr Layover $___ TONU $___ Extra stops ___ paid $___ Payment terms ___ quick pay ___ Offer $___ Counter $___ Agreed $___
Key takeaways
- Qualify the load fully before quoting: times, weight, live or drop, detention, payment terms.
- Counter with a number and a reason, and never go below the carrier's walk-away rate.
- Get every agreed detail on the rate confirmation and the carrier's approval before confirming.
Check yourself
Answer in your head first, then tap to compare.
1. The broker says detention is "standard." What should you do?
Ask for the free time and hourly rate and make sure they are written on the rate confirmation.
2. What two things can a dispatcher bring to a negotiation that a broker might not know?
The truck's true costs (deadhead, CPM) and the reload market at the destination.
3. Why let the broker give the first number?
It shows where they are starting, so you don't anchor below what they were prepared to pay.
Free THC tools for this lesson
Official sources
General information, not legal or tax advice. Rules change; confirm your situation with the agency or a professional.